top of page

Breast Implant Removal vs. Replacement: Which One Is Right for You?

Writer: Dr. Megan Dreveskracht
Dr. Megan Dreveskracht
9 minutes ago
8 min read
breast implants

"Should I take my implants out, or just put new ones in?"

If you've had Breast Implants for a while, there's a good chance this question has crossed your mind -- maybe at your annual mammogram, maybe when a friend mentioned she just had hers removed, maybe just standing in front of the mirror and acknowleding that you may be in a difference phase of life than when you had them put in. It's also one of the most common conundrums women bring to me in my Seattle plastic surgery practice. The Breast Implant Removal vs. Replacement decision isn't a math problem with one right answer. It's a personal decision, and in my opinion it has a lot more to do with where you are in your life than with the implants themselves.


Lately I've noticed a pattern. More and more, I'm seeing older women come in who actually like their implants. Nothing is wrong. They aren't in pain, and they aren't unhappy with how they look. But they know implants aren't lifetime devices, and they're doing the math: if these need to be exchanged down the road, will I be too old to want another surgery by then? Do implants even fit my lifestyle anymore? Those are really smart questions. So let's break it down.


Implants Are Not Lifetime Devices:


Let's start with the part that trips a lot of people up. Breast Implants are not designed to last forever. The FDA itself states plainly that breast implants are not considered lifetime devices. That doesn't mean they come with an expiration date stamped on the box, and it doesn't mean you need to rush in for a swap on some specific anniversary. Plenty of implants go a long time without any issue. But it does mean that when you choose to keep implants, you are choosing to keep a device that will, at some point, likely need attention -- whether that's because of a rupture (read more in my post on silent rupture), Capsular Contracture (scar tissue tightening around the implant), changes in your breasts over time, or simply a change in what you want.


I like to think of it like owning a car versus taking the bus. A car gives you something the bus never will -- you get exactly where you want to go, on your own terms. But owning a car also means oil changes, new tires, and the occasional surprise trip to the mechanic. Neither choice is right or wrong. You just need to know what you're signing up for. When you replace your implants, you aren't only making a decision about how you want to look today. You're re-committing to the maintenance plan.


Why Your Age Matters:

A birthday cake to represent considerations for breast implants in aging population.

This is exactly where those women I mentioned are being so thoughtful. Implant surgery is usually not catastrophic. For most healthy patients, a straightforward removal and replacement is a relatively minor procedure. But the older we get, the more our health history tends to grow -- and with it, the more potential there is for complications with any surgery. Something that would be a simple exchange today might be a bigger deal in twenty years, especially if it involves removing the capsule (the layer of scar tissue your body naturally forms around every implant), or if it's happening because something went wrong rather than on your own timeline.


So if you're asking yourself whether you really want to be managing implants into your 70s and 80s, that's not vanity and it's not paranoia. That's good planning. Some women weigh that and decide they're happy to keep going. Others decide this is the moment to step off the ride on their own terms, while surgery is simpler and they get to choose the date. Both are completely reasonable answers.


Implants Are Still the Most Predictable Way to Add Volume:


Now, I want to be fair to both sides here, because I'm not in the business of talking anyone into -- or out of -- implants. What's really important to understand is that implants are the most predictable, reliable way to add volume to your breasts. If your goal is to have more volume than your own breast tissue gives you, then, generally speaking, that's going to be an implant.


I get asked about Fat Grafting as an alternative all the time. Fat Grafting is a wonderful tool. It can add some strategic volume, soften contour irregularities, and help thicken up thin tissue after implants come out. But it is never going to replace an implant. Fat cells are living cells that have to develop their own blood supply to survive, so we can't just pour an implant's worth of fat into the space the implant used to occupy and expect it to stick around (I go into more detail in my post on fat grafting to the breasts). If you're hoping fat will give you the same result your implants did, you will be disappointed.


So if volume really matters to you, replacement is probably your answer. And sometimes the right answer isn't all or nothing. A smaller implant -- one that fits a little better with your current body and lifestyle -- can be a great middle ground. Just remember that a smaller implant is still an implant. You are still making that same commitment to the maintenance plan we talked about above.


Removal Means Being Okay With a Smaller Chest:


Here's the honest part. When we take implants out, we are removing volume. Your chest will be smaller. Shocker, I know -- but you'd be surprised how often that simple fact gets lost in the excitement of "I'm finally getting these out." In my opinion, the single most important question to ask yourself before Breast Implant Removal is whether you are at a point in your life where you are truly okay with feeling like your chest is small.


How much smaller, and how your breasts look afterward, depends on how much volume we're removing and on the condition of your breast tissue and skin. Some women have a good amount of their own breast tissue, and the change feels modest. Others have very little tissue sitting on top of the implant, and the change is dramatic. Many women will also need a Breast Lift at the same time to address skin the implant had been filling out for years. (If you want to dig into the factors that predict how your breasts will look after removal -- implant size, how long they've been in, tissue quality -- my post Considering Breast Implant Removal? Start Here is a great companion to this one.) Whatever your anatomy calls for, you need to be okay with accepting that, too.


It's also worth acknowledging that we feel connected to different parts of our bodies in different ways. Some women feel deeply connected to their breasts and to the way their implants make them feel. Others notice -- or have noticed for a while -- a disconnect. Their implants feel like they belong to a different chapter. If you're already at that point, then implant removal is probably a great option for you.


Accepting the Unknown:

question mark for what your breasts will look like with implant removal.

This is the part I spend the most time on in consultation. I have plenty of patients come in hoping I can essentially wave a magic wand and show them an absolute, complete picture of what their breasts will look like with their implants out -- and maybe with a Breast Lift on top of it. I wish I could. I can't. And honestly, no surgeon can.


What I can do is gather clues. I look at your nipple-areola diameter, the degree of nipple ptosis (how low your nipple sits relative to your breast fold), your sternal notch to nipple distance, your skin and tissue quality, the size of your implant, and how much of your own breast tissue is sitting on top of it. Those measurements help me extrapolate and give you a realistic range of what to expect. But it's a lot like a contractor patching a wall: you can make a really educated guess about what's behind the drywall, but you don't truly know until it's open. I don't have absolute certainty until we are in the operating room.


So you need to be okay with that uncertainty. In my experience, the women who are happiest after getting their implants out are the ones who came to me having already made a concrete decision: they just want them out. It doesn't matter exactly what their breasts end up looking like. That, in my humble opinion, is really where you need to be.


If you come to me needing a guaranteed picture of your final result before you can commit, that's an unrealistic expectation to place on me or on any surgeon. And to me, it's usually a sign that you might just not be ready to have your implants out yet. That's okay! It doesn't mean never. It just means not yet.


It's a Phase of Life, Not a Mistake:


I want to say this loud for the people in the back: choosing to remove your implants does not mean you made the wrong decision when you got them. It doesn't mean you're a different person, and it doesn't mean you were being vain or silly back then.


I explain to my patients that there are different phases of your life. Sometimes having implants matches a particular phase, and sometimes it doesn't. At one point in time, this was something that was important to you -- maybe your implants gave you confidence after breastfeeding, maybe they made your clothes fit the way you always wanted, maybe you just loved how you looked. Now, it may not be as important to you. Both of those things can be true at the same time. It's okay to accept that you're simply no longer in the phase of life where implants make sense for you.


And it works the other way, too. Deciding to replace your implants later in life isn't clinging to the past. If they still feel like you, that's a perfectly good reason to keep them.


Breast Implant Removal vs. Replacement -- How to Decide:


Everything comes down to a balance of pros and cons. Here are the questions I'd ask yourself before your consultation:


  • Do you need more volume than your own breast tissue can give you? If yes, replacement (or a smaller implant) is likely your best fit.

  • Are you genuinely okay with a smaller chest -- and possibly a Breast Lift and its scars -- if that's what your anatomy needs?

  • Can you accept not knowing exactly what your breasts will look like until after surgery?

  • Are you willing to keep up with the maintenance of an implant, possibly for the rest of your life?

  • Do your implants still feel like part of who you are, or like a chapter that has closed?


If the benefits of having implants still outweigh the commitment, the maintenance, and the potential for future surgeries, replacement makes a lot of sense. If they don't -- if the pros of having implants no longer outweigh the cons of planning around them -- removal may be exactly the right move for this phase of your life.


Bottom line: there's no wrong answer here, only the answer that fits where you are right now. Knowledge is power.


And remember, a consultation is not a commitment to surgery. Take your time, get your questions answered, and get a second opinion if you need to. If you're weighing Breast Implant Removal vs. Replacement and want to talk through what makes sense for your body and your life, I'd love to help you think it through. You can reach my downtown Seattle practice at 206.860.5582 or fill out a consultation form here.


Dr. Megan Dreveskracht is a board certified Plastic Surgeon in Seattle, Washington. She specializes in cosmetic procedures of the breast and body.


Dr. Megan Dreveskracht Board Certified Female Plastic Surgeon in Seattle, Washington.

Comments


Your journey to the confidence you deserve starts here. 

Logo for Dr. Megan Dreveskracht

1229 Madison St, Ste 1600
Seattle, WA, 98104

  • TikTok
  • Youtube
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest

© 2023 by Dr Megan Dreveskracht. Proudly created with Wix.com

bottom of page